Who decides what gets deleted on Wikipedia? What arguments win?
What this isThis is an interactive map of 382,000 Articles for Deletion decisions on Wikipedia. It has debates from 2005 to 2018. Someday, I hope to update it weekly, thus the name Wikipedia Wednesday!
My questionWikipedia explicitly says that deleting an article is “not a vote.” Editors debate, and then an uninvolved editor or administrator decides. I wanted to know who holds the power, and what arguments end up winning.
WhyWikipedia is built through collective knowledge and decision-making, but a much smaller group could shape what knowledge stays in it. I wanted to see whether that process is as shared as it seems, and saw it as a chance to experiment with using AI to map how decisions were made.
How to explore
Each bubble is a group of debates about similar topics. Scroll or pinch to zoom in, and the bubbles split into smaller topics, all the way down to single debates. Drag to move around. Hover or tap a dot to see that debate.
How to read the lines
A line joins two groups where editors made similar arguments. The thicker the line, the stronger the overlap. That doesn’t mean the same editors were there, or that the debates ended the same way. It means they read alike.
How to read a decision pathway
Dots with a black ring have a decision pathway. Click one to see the arguments grouped into boxes (navy to keep, rust to delete, mustard to merge) and lines showing how they answered each other on the way to the decision. So far, 1,941 of the most contested and interesting debates have one.